2nd Circuit Summarily Affirms Grant of Summary Judgment to National Bank Based on EFTA Bona Fide Error Defense
The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit summarily affirmed a New York federal court’s order granting summary judgment, based on the bona fide error defense, to the defendant–national bank as to Electronic Fund Transfer Act (EFTA) claims alleging that the bank inadequately investigated and did not promptly reimburse the plaintiff-consumer for unauthorized transfers.
EFTA states that a person cannot be held liable under a private cause of action “if the person shows by a preponderance of evidence that the violation was not intentional and resulted from a bona fide error notwithstanding the maintenance of procedures reasonably adapted to avoid any such error.” The consumer argued that this so-called bona fide error defense does not apply to another section of EFTA setting forth obligations that she alleges the bank violated. The Second Circuit rejected this argument. The court reasoned that, because the section authorizing the private right of action under which the consumer sued also creates this defense, the defense plainly applies to her claims here.
The consumer also argued that the bona fide error defense is limited to clerical mistakes and does not apply where, as alleged here, the bank made a factual error in investigating the unauthorized transfers. The Second Circuit also rejected this argument. For one thing, the court observed that the above-quoted statutory section does not use the word “clerical.” For another thing, the court observed that the U.S. Supreme Court has previously held that this defense applies to both clerical and factual errors.
