WBK Industry - Litigation Developments

NC Federal Court Approves $9 Million Settlement Resolving Suit over Fees for Telephonic Mortgage Payments

The U.S. District Court for the Middle District of North Carolina has approved a $9,000,000 settlement resolving claims alleging that a mortgage lender’s $9.50 fee for making telephonic payments violated the North Carolina Debt Collection Act (NCDCA) and the North Carolina Unfair and Deceptive Trade Practices Act (NCUDTPA).

As background, the named plaintiff–borrower filed a class action against the defendant–mortgage lender, alleging that the $9.50 fee charged to make mortgage payments by telephone (so-called “pay-to-pay” fees) violated the NCDCA and the NCUDTPA.  The court then denied the defendant’s ensuing motion to dismiss and certified a class as to both counts.  The class included: “All persons (1) with a residential mortgage loan securing a property in North Carolina, (2) serviced or subserviced by [the defendant], (3) and who paid a pay-to-pay fee to [the defendant] when making a payment on their mortgage by telephone or an Interactive Voice Response system between April 10, 2020, and January 13, 2026.”

Subsequently, the parties settled.  Pursuant to the settlement, the defendant agreed to pay $9 million into a settlement fund — which corresponds to about $670 in recovery per fee paid by a class member.  After deducting costs associated with administering the settlement fund, each class member is to receive about $425 per fee paid.  The defendant also agreed to stop charging “pay-to-pay” fees unless a change in the law subsequently authorizes them. 

In approving the settlement, the court determined that it was fair because: “the parties vigorously represented their interests in multiple motions”; the parties completed formal discovery, which enabled class counsel to engage in informed settlement negotiations; and the parties in fact engaged in multiple mediation sessions and arm’s-length settlement negotiations over the course of a month.  The court also determined that the settlement was adequate because: the defendant had raised several defenses that created “risks associated with bringing this case to trial”; the $670 per violation amount exceeded the $500 per violation minimum set by the NCDCA; the settlement also provided for injunctive relief; and the notice sent to class members explained the opt-out and objection processes, and no class member filed an objection or opted out.