WBK Industry - Litigation Developments

Federal Court Partially Dismisses Medical Providers’ Claims in Medical Debt Suit Against Credit Bureaus, Allows Collection Agency’s Claims to Proceed

A California federal court recently dismissed antitrust claims filed by the medical provider plaintiffs but not those filed by the collection agency plaintiff in a case related to the reporting of medical debt to the credit bureaus.  The plaintiffs’ claims and alleged injuries stem from the defendant credit bureaus no longer including certain unpaid medical debt in credit reports.  The plaintiffs allege, in part, that this change injured them because consumers now have less incentive to pay their medical debt.

The court had previously dismissed claims brought by the medical provider plaintiffs, but allowed them to file an amended complaint.  The amended complaint added the collection agency as a plaintiff.  The court allowed the collection agency plaintiff’s claims to proceed because it was a participant in the relevant market, and alleged a direct relationship with the credit bureaus.  Due to the credit bureaus’ agreement not to report certain unpaid medical debt, the collection agency alleged a “devalued service” that made it more difficult for it to collect on unpaid debt.  

On the other hand, the medical provider plaintiffs’ antitrust claims were dismissed for lack of standing, because, among other factors, the court found that the medical provider plaintiffs did not allege a plausible agency relationship between themselves and the collection agency plaintiffs such that the injuries to the collection agencies could be considered injuries to the medical providers.  One of the reasons the court did not view the medical provider plaintiffs and the collection agency plaintiff to have an agency relationship was due to the collection agency plaintiff’s ability to independently decide the “tools” it used to secure repayment.  The court also found that the medical provider plaintiffs could not establish an antitrust injury, because they were not participants in the relevant market.

The medical provider plaintiffs also claimed tortious interference with contract under California and New Jersey law based on the contracts between the medical providers and their patients requiring that the patients pay for services.  The Court preserved these claims at this motion to dismiss stage.