D.C. Federal Court Holds that President’s Removal Without Cause of NCUA Board Members Was Illegal
In a recent order, the U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia held that the President’s removal of two board members of the National Credit Union Administration (NCUA) violated the Federal Credit Union Act (FCUA) and required reinstatement of the members.
Congress amended the FCUA in 1978 to replace the previous structure of a single administrator — who served “at the pleasure of the President” without a defined term — with a multimember board whose members serve fixed six-year terms. And as the U.S. Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit explained in a previous case, the legislative history shows that the relevant Senate committee understood the six-year terms to protect NCUA board members from at-will removal during their appointed terms.
Moreover, the multimember board structure of the NCUA mirrors that of other agencies (such as the FTC) whose members enjoy protection from at-will removal under existing Supreme Court precedent. In a 90-year-old case, the Supreme Court held that various non-executive characteristics of the FTC (such as its legislative function in reporting to Congress and its judicial function in holding administrative hearings) were inconsistent with permitting the President to remove the agency’s commissioners at will.
More recently, though, the Supreme Court stayed lower court orders enjoining the President from firing members of the NLRB, Merit Systems Protection Board (MSPB), and Consumer Product Safety Commission (CPSC). In effect, the President can fire members of these agency boards and commissions pending appeals. Notably, the order addressing the CPSC stated that this commission “exercises executive power in a similar manner as the National Labor Relations Board.” This statement stands in contrast to the Court’s previous characterization of agencies like the FTC.
Accordingly, the district court concluded that these circumstances indicate that the FCUA precludes the President from removing NCUA board members without cause. Relatedly, the court also determined that such removal protection — as the Supreme Court has held with respect to other agencies like the FTC — is consistent with the constitutional principle of separation of powers. Finally, the court determined that reinstatement is a proper remedy under prevailing D.C. Circuit precedent.
Without deciding the merits of the case, however, the D.C. Circuit subsequently issued an order staying the district court’s order.
