WBK Industry - Federal Regulatory Developments

CFPB Proposes Deletion of References to Consumer Education and Financial Literacy in Civil Penalty Fund Rule

On June 18, the CFPB published a proposed amendment to a 2013 rule governing the consumer financial civil penalty fund, which would remove language allowing the Bureau to allocate money for consumer education and financial literacy.

The Consumer Financial Protection Act established the civil penalty fund to pool monies that the CFPB collects from civil fines in enforcement actions.  The Bureau draws monies from this fund to compensate injured consumers in cases where they would not otherwise receive compensation, such as if a bankrupt or dissolved defendant cannot pay restitution.  Currently, the Bureau may also allocate monies from the fund for consumer education and financial literacy if all eligible consumers have been compensated or if making payment to consumers is infeasible.

According to the proposed rule, “the procedures outlined in the [2013] rule provide neither adequate guardrails for the agency’s exercise of its discretion nor adequate transparency to the public regarding a potentially significant expenditure.”  The preamble to the 2013 rule explained that ‘‘the Bureau has adopted criteria — not contained in this rule — for selecting the particular consumer education or financial literacy programs to be funded’’ and cited a page on the Bureau’s website.  The text of the 2013 rule mentioned the phrase ‘‘allocating funds to consumer education and financial literacy programs’’ only twice and did not further clarify how the Bureau would allocate those funds.

Without adequate guardrails, the proposed rule concludes, “there could be incentives to bring enforcement actions for the purpose of aggrandizing the operational scope of the agency.”